Lewiston councilors steer mobile home lot rent ordinance toward 5% cap ahead of Nov. 24 vote
Residents of Fox Run Mobile Home Park urged councilors to protect seniors on fixed incomes. An informal count backed capping yearly increases at the lesser of inflation plus 1% or 5%, with lots below about $575 exempt.
LEWISTON, Maine — Lewiston city councilors on Tuesday gave the city attorney direction on a long-debated mobile home lot rent stabilization ordinance, settling informally on a cap of inflation plus 1% or 5% a year, whichever is less, ahead of a first-reading vote set for Nov. 24.
The council has been working on the ordinance since adopting a moratorium on lot rent increases in March. It took no formal vote Tuesday; councilors used a show of thumbs to tell the city attorney what to put in the draft.
What councilors agreed on
The housing committee's recommendation, which councilors chose to work from, would:
- Limit yearly increases to the regional consumer price index plus 1%. After a back-and-forth, four councilors agreed to add a 5% ceiling, the cap residents had sought.
- Exempt lots whose rent after an increase would stay below a threshold tied to fair market rent for a two-bedroom apartment. The committee recommended 31%, or about $520 a month; four councilors agreed to raise it to 34%, which a councilor said would be about $575.
- Count all recurring charges, including water and sewer, as part of base rent.
- Drop the earlier draft's provisions aimed at large institutional investors.
Housing committee chair Craig Saddlemire told the council the threshold would adjust each year with fair market rent. He said the committee had voted 6-2 for its recommendation.
Councilor Bret Martel argued for a higher threshold, saying moving a mobile home can cost $10,000 or more and that cracking down too hard on park owners could push them to sell the land for other uses. "There's a fundamental difference between inflation and exploitation," he said.
Councilor Joshua Nagine said he would support the higher threshold only with the 5% cap, noting that inflation plus 1% could otherwise top 5% in a high-inflation year.
City Attorney Mike Carey told councilors that changing the percentage once the ordinance is drafted would likely require another first reading.
Residents ask for protection
During public comment, residents of Fox Run Mobile Home Park described living on Social Security. One said three-quarters of the park's residents are seniors and asked for a cap of "the lesser of CPI or 5 percent." Another said he and his partner, both disabled, pay $470 a month and could end up living in their cars if lot rent climbs past $500.
Dan Newman, an organizer with the Maine Labor Climate Council, said 16 Maine towns have passed lot rent stabilization ordinances, eight of them by referendum on Nov. 3.
A park owner said residents don't understand what it costs to run a park, noting that the city does not plow the park's roads or supply its water.
Other business
The council voted 7-0 to let the city administrator cut the sale price of city-owned land on Old Lisbon Road to Hebert Development from $750,000 to $500,000. City economic development staff said wetlands, an old railroad bed and long utility runs had cut the number of homes the site could hold from an early estimate of 277 to about 60.
Councilors also agreed by consensus to hold a special election April 13 to fill the Ward 3 seat of Councilor Scott Harriman, who is resigning. The council plans a formal vote on the date Nov. 24.