Windham lawmaker seeks citizenship checks on every voter in her district as recount begins
Rep. Barbara Bagshaw, who trails Democrat Bradley Youngs by 139 votes, asked the secretary of state for records on whether voters in House District 106 were run through a federal citizenship database.
AUGUSTA, Maine — Republican state Rep. Barbara Bagshaw of Windham has asked the Maine Secretary of State's Office for records on the citizenship of every voter who cast a ballot in her House district, as a hand recount of her losing reelection race got underway Wednesday in Augusta.
Bagshaw trails Democrat Bradley Youngs by 139 votes in House District 106 in preliminary results from the Nov. 3 election, the secretary of state's office reported.
"The recount is beginning. We just served the secretary of State office with A FOAA request," Bagshaw wrote in a post on X on Wednesday morning. "We requested an extended audit but we were told we had to do the recount first. Please share."
The request, made under Maine's Freedom of Access Act and dated Nov. 17, is addressed to Secretary of State Shenna Bellows. Bagshaw posted images of the two-page letter with her post.
What she asked for
The letter seeks records identifying everyone who voted in District 106 on Nov. 3, absentee or in person, including names, home addresses, voter identification numbers and how and where each person voted, to the extent those records are public.
It also asks for any citizenship verification, immigration-status check or eligibility confirmation done on voters in the district, and for all records on whether the state used the federal Systematic Alien Verification for Entitlements program, known as SAVE, to check the citizenship of voters in the district or statewide. SAVE is run by the U.S. Department of Homeland Security.
The letter asks for any queries the state sent to SAVE, any results it got back, its internal policies on whether to use the system, and its communications with federal agencies about the Nov. 3 election. It also seeks any records of known or suspected noncitizen registrations or votes tied to the district, and any statements by Bellows or her office acknowledging that noncitizens have voted or registered in Maine, "including the 'isolated instances' previously referenced," according to the letter.
The request covers records from about Oct. 1 to the present and asks for a written acknowledgment within five working days.
Earlier claims
On a Nov. 6 appearance on the "Voice of Maine" radio show, Bagshaw said Windham's same-day voter registration lines were filled with people she called "foreign looking" who arrived in large numbers late in the day, the Portland Press Herald reported.
Windham Town Clerk Anthony Blasi told the Press Herald the town did not see an unusual number of voter registrations for a statewide election and that a late-day rush of voters on Election Day is not uncommon.
Bagshaw told Maine Morning Star she received dozens of calls from constituents urging her to request a recount, that outlet reported.
The recount
Preliminary results gave Youngs 2,637 votes to Bagshaw's 2,498, according to the Press Herald. Because the margin was larger than the threshold for a state-paid recount, Bagshaw was required to pay a deposit to request one, the newspaper reported.
In a recount, representatives for both candidates and secretary of state staff review every paper ballot by hand to set the official totals. The District 106 recount is one of four the secretary of state's office scheduled this week, The Signal reported Monday.
Bagshaw has represented part of Windham in the Maine House since 2022.