Bridgewater council delays vote on removing town manager until investigation is done
Councilors also kept alive a colleague's resolution distancing the council from Councilor MJ Spagone's public comments about the town manager.
BRIDGEWATER, Mass. — The Bridgewater Town Council voted 7-2 on Tuesday to put off until Dec. 15 a resolution that would remove Town Manager Justin Casanova-Davis, with several councilors saying they want to see the results of an independent investigation the council commissioned first.
At-large Councilor Michaela "MJ" Spagone, who filed the resolution, read it into the record at the Nov. 17 meeting. It says "there have been questions as to the professional integrity of the town manager," that he has "inadequately accounted for or not summarily explained" his time off, that he has been "unwilling to answer questions from the public regarding water," and that he "continues to demonstrate a level of secrecy, obstruction, and misinformation." It says residents "have lost confidence" in him and calls for the council to use its authority under the town charter to remove him, effective Nov. 17.
NBC10 Boston has reported that an investigation found Casanova-Davis did not key into his Town Hall office for 44 days.
Spagone said she had expected the resolution to coincide with the investigation report, which has not been delivered, and that she would welcome an amendment changing the date. "It is not a singular opinion of a few people, it is a great many individuals," she said, adding that she had endorsed Casanova-Davis when he was being interviewed for the job.
Councilor Kevin Perry moved to postpone the resolution to the council's Dec. 15 meeting, saying councilors expect the investigation results by the end of the month or early December.
Councilor Sean Kennedy said the charter requires a preliminary resolution of removal adopted by a majority of the full council, which may suspend the town manager for up to 30 days, and said the document before the council was not sufficient. He said any such resolution should be written by legal counsel and that the measure was "getting ahead of that investigation that we as a council all voted in favor of." Kennedy noted that residents had raised "the 44 days" and said the town manager had sent councilors additional information that was not reported.
Councilor Mark Linde said he objected to the resolution's title. "It assumes guilt before an investigation takes place," he said, while adding that he wants the investigation finished "sooner than later." Councilor Adelene Ellenberg said she feared the investigation would be "unduly delayed" and suggested a middle ground, such as putting the town manager on unpaid leave with the possibility of reinstatement.
Councilor Mary McGrath said the council should instead act only on what the investigation finds, with a new resolution written afterward if needed. Kennedy and McGrath voted against the postponement, according to the roll call.
The room was crowded and at times loud. During the debate, one councilor said some of the evening's speakers were "actively members of a particular political party that want to push a specific agenda," prompting someone in the audience to call out, "Shame on you." Earlier, during public comment, several residents praised Spagone. "Councillor Spagone said what residents have been saying for months," one resident said.
Resolution on Spagone's comments
The council also took up a resolution from McGrath regarding Spagone's public statements about the town manager. McGrath said speaking publicly about a matter under investigation "opens the town up for a lawsuit," and that passing the resolution would create an official record that could be used in court to protect the town. "I'm in no way preventing free speech," she said.
Spagone said she had spoken to NBC10 Boston as an individual, not on behalf of the council, and that the measure "will not stop me from speaking." "I am done being quiet," she said. Council President Paul Murphy disputed her earlier statement that he had given her permission for the interview, saying he did not and that she did not need it.
Ellenberg called McGrath's resolution "overreach" and said it should be defeated. Councilor Timothy Trocchio said there were "ulterior motives that are far beyond just the town manager," including changing the form of government. Perry said some of the resolution's language should be edited.
The council voted 8-1 to keep McGrath's resolution before the council, where it will appear on the next agenda.