The New England Signal
Independent journalism covering all six New England states
Massachusetts

Stoughton Town Meeting limits town role in federal civil immigration enforcement

Supporters said the new bylaw keeps town staff, buildings and records out of civil immigration work without stopping ICE or local police from doing their jobs.

STOUGHTON, Mass. — Stoughton Town Meeting members voted 65-27 Monday night, with two abstentions, to adopt a bylaw limiting how town employees and resources can be used in federal civil immigration enforcement, according to video of the special town meeting.

Under Article 13, a petitioned article, town personnel may not volunteer staff time, vehicles, facilities, surveillance systems or non-public information to help with civil immigration enforcement unless the law requires cooperation or the bylaw allows it. The bylaw also bars discrimination in town services based on actual or perceived immigration or citizenship status, except where the law requires otherwise.

Two town committees recommended approval. The Municipal Regulations Committee backed it 3-1 and the Intergovernmental Relations Committee 6-1, the moderator said.

"The title is long, the principle is simple," said Town Meeting member Steve Cavey of Precinct 8, who submitted the motion. He said Stoughton's employees and resources "should not be voluntarily used to enforce federal civil immigration law" unless the law requires it.

Cavey spent much of his presentation on what the bylaw does not do. "It does not stop immigration and custom enforcement from operating in Stoughton," he said. He said it does not authorize anyone to obstruct a federal agent, does not prevent police from investigating crimes, making lawful arrests or responding to emergencies, and does not let the town ignore a court order.

The bylaw sets up designated contacts, written procedures and training for employees who may be handed immigration documents. Requests for information or help would be documented, with aggregate figures included in the town's annual report, Cavey said. He said it can be carried out with existing staff and no new spending.

A second supporter said the bylaw clarifies and expands on a state law signed in August. "There's nothing particularly radical about it," he said, adding that it largely writes down what has long been the status quo.

During questions, one member asked how police could know whether a person's immigration case was civil or criminal if the bylaw kept them from contacting federal authorities. Supporters answered that immigration status is generally not relevant to criminal investigations, and that federal authorities with reason to pursue someone can get a judicial warrant.

Another member said the bylaw's disciplinary section was inconsistent: some provisions protect employees who share information unknowingly, while another allows termination without that distinction.

Massachusetts