The New England Signal
Independent journalism covering all six New England states
Massachusetts

Lakeville Town Meeting rejects ban on Flock license plate cameras after police chief's warning

The citizen petition would also have barred "biometric surveillance." Chief Matt Perkins said that wording could reach fingerprint and DNA databases.

LAKEVILLE, Mass. — Voters at a Lakeville special town meeting on Nov. 18 rejected a citizen petition that would have banned the town's Flock license plate camera and other surveillance technology, after Police Chief Matt Perkins told them the bylaw was so broad it could block police from using fingerprints and DNA, according to video of the meeting.

Article 9 would have added a bylaw titled "Prohibition of Automated License Plate Readers and Biometric Surveillance Systems." It failed on a show of voting cards. The moderator did not announce a count.

Petitioner Maureen Candito said the measure was "not any indictment" of the police department, but "a reflection of technology that has outpaced the ability to control it." Citing a Boston Globe report, she said more than 100 Massachusetts cities and towns have contracts with Flock or similar license plate camera companies, and that more than 40 of them have since repealed, paused or banned the cameras.

"We don't own the data that goes through those license plate readers," Candito said. "We don't know what happens with the data after, and we have no control over the data."

Neither the finance committee nor the select board made a recommendation. Both said they do not take positions on citizen petitions.

Chief: one camera, 30 days of images

Perkins said Lakeville has one Flock camera, at the intersection of Routes 18 and 105. It photographs passing vehicles and keeps the images for 30 days, he said, and alerts police to stolen cars and vehicles tied to Amber and Silver alerts. The town pays $3,000 a year on a year-to-year contract, he said.

He said police have used the system for about two and a half years in human trafficking, drug, break-in and stolen vehicle cases. Last month, he said, it helped officers find a missing Lakeville girl in New York and bring her home. In 2024, he said, it helped them find a resident who was being scammed just before she put $20,000 into a Bitcoin ATM in Raynham.

"In my professional opinion, with regards to solving major crime and locating missing people, Flock is one of the greatest law enforcement tools to be deployed," Perkins said.

He also acknowledged public distrust of the cameras. "We find ourselves in the middle of a crisis due to officer abuse, misinformation and the unknown," he said. He said he had added safeguards against abuse. Asked whether Lakeville had any reported or suspected misuse of the data, he said no.

Perkins said the bylaw's definition of biometric surveillance would reach the state and national fingerprint and DNA databases that police use for arrests, crime scenes and firearms licenses. He said it would also stop police from using a homeowner's doorbell video of a crime, make such evidence inadmissible in court and let officers be sued for using it.

Legal concerns

Town counsel Katherine Feodoroff of Mead, Talerman & Costa told voters that several definitions in the article were broad enough to cover cameras already in use at town buildings and schools. She said the clause letting residents sue would likely be struck down regardless, because courts, not town meeting, decide who has standing to sue. She also said requiring the town to end its existing contract carried some legal risk, but declined to discuss it in detail in public.

Candito then moved to strip out the biometric provisions and the enforcement and lawsuit section. She said that language was modeled on bylaws in other communities. Select Board member Paul Hunt, speaking as a resident, said the topic was "too important" to rewrite on the floor. The amendment failed.

Residents split

Michelle Bouchard, who said she has worked as a criminal and intelligence analyst with police for more than 25 years, said the article painted "with a very broad brush." She said it would also stop state police and neighboring departments from using their own cameras while passing through town. "If it's about Flock owning the data, then let's make it just about Flock," she said.

Paul Stone backed the petition. "You don't track everybody just to catch a few criminals, and that's what's happening here," he said. He added that "citizens have been giving up our privacy way too easily."

Nathan Darling, who said he is a father of four, urged voters to handle any concerns through policy set by the select board with the chief rather than "handcuff" police.

Voters ended debate 86-9 before rejecting the article.

Lakeville's vote goes the other way from several recent moves to limit the cameras south of Boston. Newton and Braintree are weighing a moratorium and a pause, and Bridgewater's council has advanced a plan to remove them, The Signal has reported.

At the same meeting, voters approved a separate citizen petition setting maintenance standards and fines for blighted commercial, industrial and business properties.

Massachusetts
Add The New England Signal as a preferred source on Google